SUMATERA TRAGEDY 2025: DEFORESTATION, MUDSLIDES, AND A SERIOUS WARNING TO MALAYSIA
Date: 7 December 2025
By: Khairul Faizi Ahmad Kamil, Minda Sejahtera Resources
Introduction: A Disaster Beyond Nature
Mudslides and landslides have so far claimed over 940 lives in West Sumatra, Aceh, and several other regions, and this is not merely an ecological tragedy. It exposes governance failures, lapses in enforcement, and human greed towards forests.
Indonesia’s Minister of Forestry, Raja Juli Antoni, was finally forced to heed public pressure when today he announced that the Indonesian Government would revoke the permits of 20 companies accused of causing large-scale environmental damage following the catastrophic floods and landslides in Sumatra. These areas cover approximately 750,000 hectares, an area roughly the size of Selangor.
Viral footage showing logs swept away by floodwaters shocked the world, revealing that this disaster was man-made and built over many years without public awareness.
Malaysia, as a country sharing similar geography, tropical climate, soil structures, and development pressures, must regard this tragedy as the loudest warning in decades: deforestation is a ticking disaster bomb.
1. Lost forests are a collapsed shield against disasters
Aerial footage from Sumatra clearly shows bare hillsides, areas once lush are now exposed soil fields. The land easily slides, rivers are blocked, and floods transform into destructive mudflows that obliterate villages in moments.
Malaysia has witnessed smaller warnings: the Gunung Inas tragedy, Cameron Highlands mud floods, and erosion in Gua Musang. Forests are the country’s “green infrastructure.” If they collapse, the entire disaster ecology collapses with them.
2. Weak enforcement opens the door to tragedy
In Sumatra, illegal logging occurred openly and extensively. Even legal concessions were exploited beyond limits. Inspections were rare, monitoring systems outdated, and field loopholes allowed syndicates to profit without concern for community risk.
Remember: a single logging truck leaving without approval today could be the cause of a death tomorrow.
Enforcement without technology is a structural weakness that can be fatal. It must be enhanced; relying solely on old-fashioned enforcement is insufficient.
3. Environmental corruption is a silent killer
Indonesia revoked permits for 20 companies covering 750,000 hectares. Preliminary investigations suggest over-logging and permit misuse. The pressing question for Malaysia is: are our permit systems strong enough to withstand corporate and political pressure?
Necessary measures include:
- open tender systems for forest concessions,
- public disclosure of permit locations,
- third-party monitoring by academia, NGOs, and media,
- regular integrity audits specifically for land-use projects.
Environmental corruption does not only harm the government, it claims lives.
4. Transparency is a vaccine against natural disasters
Residents of Sumatra only learned the scale of destruction after the viral footage circulated. If information had been released earlier, public pressure might have prevented further damage, as the consequences are ultimately borne by the people.
In Malaysia, access to forest maps, EIA reports, and concession data remains limited. The country can emulate models like Norway and Canada, which mandate public disclosure for all land-use changes. When the public can observe, governments and companies act more cautiously.
5. Major disasters do not happen suddenly, they are built slowly
Every uncontrolled tree felled increases future risk. Every exposed slope loosens soil structure. Every disrupted river reduces flood absorption capacity.
The Sumatra disaster did not begin with the rain; it began years earlier as forests were cleared tree by tree.
Malaysia must strengthen the Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) approach in development policies. All projects, especially in sensitive areas, should undergo rigorous risk assessment. Development without DRR is like building a house without a solid foundation.
The 100 million tree planting project (2021–2025), has it been successful in addressing deforestation and logging issues?
6. Citizens are the frontline of disaster prevention
The viral video of logs swept away forced the Indonesian government to act. This demonstrates the crucial role of communities in preventing environmental damage.
Malaysia can emulate this model by:
- encouraging reporting via official complaint apps,
- providing protection to whistleblowers,
- allowing media and NGOs to conduct independent monitoring.
- When communities are involved, disasters are more easily prevented.
Conclusion: Sumatra’s Tragedy as a Mirror for Malaysia
Deforestation, illegal logging, and high-risk development are not exclusive to Indonesia. Malaysia has faced and continues to face similar challenges.
Forests are the defense.
Integrity is the key.
Enforcement is the shield.
Transparency is the oversight.
If Malaysia learns from this experience, we still have time to prevent disasters. If we are careless, Sumatra 2025 is only a “trailer” of what could happen here.
Ulasan
Catat Ulasan